Trying to make sense of this Yasiel Puig-Corey Kluber rumor


While Robinson Cano and Edwin Diaz (siiiiigh) are about to get dealt to the Mets, there’s a Dodger rumor that won’t seem to die down.

The Dodgers, apparently, are really interested in Cleveland starting pitcher Corey Kluber. It’s hard to blame them, as Kluber is one of the best starting pitchers in baseball. In an era in which starting pitchers don’t throw as many innings as they used to, Kluber has logged 200 or more innings in five consecutive seasons. That has its pluses and minuses, which we’ll get to shortly.

The rumor, as it stands right now, is a bit of a head-scratcher. Yasiel Puig seems to be the centerpiece being mentioned from the Dodgers’ end. The same Yasiel Puig who, three summers ago was placed on waivers and two summers ago was optioned to Triple-A. A strong 2017 and 2018, plus strong postseason performances, have raised his standing across the league.

But I’m still not exactly sure what to make of this rumor. Here’s a short tweet thread from yours truly:

I get it. Puig is good. He’s coming off a season in which he posted a 123 wRC+ and played a very strong right field. Meanwhile, Cleveland is in desperate need of outfielders. They have been for quite awhile, and they’re likely to lose Michael Brantley to free agency. Here is a look at the outfielders on their 40-man roster:

Jason Kipnis is also there, but he’s a shell of his former self and is much, much better at second base than the outfield.

Alex did a good job looking at potential targets in an article the day before Thanksgiving, and touched on the Cleveland outfield situation in a little more depth.

“Cleveland’s interest in an outfielder also makes sense. Michael Brantley made 134 starts in left field last season and will likely get a nice contract elsewhere. Outside of him, no other outfielder had more than 300 plate appearances for Cleveland last season. Bradley Zimmer hasn’t quite lived up to his former top-prospect status and had shoulder surgery in July that was estimated to keep him out for 8-12 months. They acquired Leonys Martin at the trade deadline last season, but he only had 17 plate appearances before contracting a life-threatening bacteria.”

Editor’s Note: Martin was given a clean bill of health on Nov. 20.

So yeah, their interest in Puig makes sense. But for Kluber? That’s where I get tripped up. Despite going into his age-33 season, Kluber still has plenty of trade value. He’s signed through the 2019 season with two very affordable options for 2020 and 2021. In effect, he’s signed for three more seasons at $38.5 million. Only $15 million of it is guaranteed, but the most attractive thing for the Dodgers (and I hate that this still might be a thing) is the fact his luxury/competitive balance tax number through this season is just $7.7 million. That’s a downright steal. That number will increase if/when his options are exercised.

Which brings us back to the main question: Why Puig? Why not Puig and another more controllable outfielder like Joc Pederson (two years) or Alex Verdugo (six years)? And if that weren’t confusing enough, check out these grafs from the Morosi article:

“The Dodgers would need to add at least one significant player in addition to Puig in order for the Indians to seriously consider moving Kluber, one source said Wednesday. MLB Network insider Ken Rosenthal was first to report the talks between the Dodgers and Indians. In addition to Puig, the Dodgers have catching-prospect depth and would likely be willing to move left-hander Alex Wood and right-handed prospect Yadier Alvarez, who was just recently added to Los Angeles’ 40-man roster.”

Huh? Alvarez isn’t terribly surprising, but Wood? I’m reasonably sure he’ll be moved this offseason, but I really can’t see it happening in this deal. He’s projected to make $9 million in his last year of arbitration, so that would mean Cleveland is taking on $20 million in Puig and Wood for this season while giving up the rest of Kluber’s guaranteed $15 million? That doesn’t make sense. Maybe this isn’t meant to be the offer, but it is written a bit weirdly.

For argument’s sake, let’s just say Puig and Alvarez are involved. Surely there would need to be another significant player heading to Cleveland. They still want to compete and play in the game’s weakest division, so another trip to the postseason is likely to happen. They aren’t rebuilding, so they probably won’t want a prospect who’s a couple years away and I really can’t see them taking Wood. What about Ross Stripling? Would make sense.

If the Dodgers land Kluber, he’s in the rotation along with Clayton Kershaw, Walker Buehler and Hyun-Jin Ryu. That doesn’t even take into account Rich Hill, Kenta Maeda or Julio Urias. While Stripling performed well in the bullpen when asked, his desire is to return to the starting rotation — where he was an All-Star in 2018. He’d be the kind of piece Cleveland would like in return. He’s not arbitration-eligible until next winter, so he’s locked up for four more years. It’d be tough to lose him, but it makes a potential deal a lot more realistic (to me, at least). Still, I can’t think Cleveland would be missing a chance to add one more outfielder. Oh well.


As for Kluber himself, the dude is a stud. He has been at least a 5-win pitcher in five consecutive seasons, and twice he has been a 7-win pitcher. That’s elite territory.

Since 2014, he has been the most valuable pitcher in baseball. Yes, even more valuable than Kershaw (in, admittedly, almost 200 more innings pitched). He owns a 2.85 ERA, 2.84 FIP and the 4th-best K-BB% in the game (23.3 percent) behind Chris Sale, Kershaw and Max Scherzer. In case you were still wondering how good this guy has been. Even with a slight “decline” in 2018, he still posted a 2.89 ERA, 3.12 FIP and a 22.3 K-BB%. What’s becoming more apparent, though, is that his ridiculous 2017 season (2.25 ERA, 2.50 FIP, 29.5 K-BB%, 35.6 O-Swing%, 15.6 SwStr%) was his peak. So 2018 seems less like age starting to catch up to him and more like a return to his normal great self after an otherworldly 2017.

Kluber doesn’t do it with elite velocity. His fastball averaged 92.54 MPH last season, while his sinker was 92.6, which he throws almost four times as much as his 4-seamer. He also throws his 89 MPH cutter almost 30 percent of the time and has a mid-80s slider that he throws more than 20 percent of the time. He’s mainly a 3-pitch pitcher, but all three of those pitchers are well above-average. The best thing about Kluber is the fact he doesn’t walk hitters. He has a career 5.6 percent walk rate and is coming off his best season in 2018 (4 BB%). He also does something the Dodgers covet — he minimizes hard contact. He had an average exit velocity against last season of 87.3 MPH, just a tenth of a point better than Wood. Kluber is also a mid-40 percent ground ball guy and does a relatively good job of keeping the ball in the ballpark (1.05 HR/9 last season, 0.88 HR/9 for his career).


The Dodgers would be taking a bit of a gamble on Kluber. The financial commitment isn’t prohibitive, but they would be acquiring a guy who is at the end of an incredible (and arbitrary) 5-year run and will be hoping he can be that guy for his age 33-35 seasons. They’re not averse to having older starting pitchers. They traded for Hill in his age-36 season. They signed Brandon McCarthy to a 4-year deal (his age 31-34 seasons). They signed 32-year-old Scott Kazmir to a 3-year deal. Only one of them have worked out well, but obviously Kluber is in a different class.

The reported interest in Puig is still puzzling to me (as opposed to Pederson or Verdugo and others), but if that’s who Cleveland wants, so be it. If this rumor really has legs, there’s a non-zero chance it gets done before today’s 5 p.m. tender deadline. The Dodgers have 10 remaining arbitration-eligible players on whom they must decide today. One of them is Puig. There’s no rule a deal has to be done today, but it wouldn’t be the most surprising thing to see.

I don’t want to see Puig play for a different team, but this is probably the Dodgers’ last best chance to trade him. And if they do, well:

Bryce Harper, please.

About Dustin Nosler

Avatar photo
Dustin Nosler began writing about the Dodgers in July 2009 at his blog, Feelin' Kinda Blue. He co-hosted a weekly podcast with Jared Massey called Dugout Blues. He was a contributor/editor at The Hardball Times and True Blue LA. He graduated from California State University, Sacramento, with his bachelor’s degree in journalism and a minor in digital media. While at CSUS, he worked for the student-run newspaper The State Hornet for three years, culminating with a 1-year term as editor-in-chief. He resides in Stockton, Calif.