Days after the Rule 5 Draft protection deadline finally led to some roster news, the non-tender deadline finalized more spots that included at least one pleasantly unexpected move.
Since last month’s article previewing this decision day, there was movement among the six (well, five, then six again) arbitration-eligible players they had that we’ll go through individually here. Additionally, the previously 17 pre-arb players on the 40-man saw four additions at the aforementioned protection deadline (plus the subtraction of one pre-arb player) that ran that total to 20.
Note: All arbitration estimates are via MLB Trade Rumors.
======
RHP Brock Stewart – 5 Years 93 Days Service Time – Arbitration 3 – $1.8MM Projected
Prediction: Tendered
Result: Tendered
I didn’t exactly go out on a limb here, as when healthy Stewart was used by Dave Roberts like a leverage option, for better or worse. Evan Phillips‘ exit made this even more of a lock than it was previously, and him being available and productive looks oddly important in 2027 … again, for better or worse.
3B/1B/2B Royce Lewis – 4 Years 139 Days Service Time – Arbitration 3 – $5.1MM Projected
Prediction: None
Result: Tendered
There was no prediction because he was just acquired at the non-tender deadline for a deal that involved pre-arb guy Bobby Miller, as Dustin recently covered. Before that, he was actually a non-tender candidate for the Twins due to his salary almost doubling due to him being a Super Two that’s in his third year of arbitration, despite putting up a .231/.285/.384/.669 line over 900 PA in the last two seasons for ~1.5 WAR. Still, the combination of upside from his first three seasons (.268/.327/.497/.825) and his ability to play third to spell Max Muncy, first to spell Freddie Freeman, and even second to perhaps play there against lefties made him appealing to the Dodgers in particular. Both the price and the bet on the player bouncing back makes sense for the team.
RHP Jake Cousins – 4 Years 91 Days Service Time – Arbitration 2 – $1.0MM Projected
Prediction: Tendered
Result: Designated For Assignment/Non-Tendered
Oopsie. My assumption was the Dodgers wouldn’t have signed Cousins while he was recovering from a mid-2025 Tommy John surgery if they weren’t planning on actually keeping him for the team control years he still had even after 2026, especially since there wasn’t anything in his stuff when he made rehab appearances last year that indicated he was any different than the guy they inked. The Dodgers definitely had other candidates to cut from the 40-man if they wanted, so this was a bit of a surprise for me. Well, I guess if they don’t think he’s a useful pen arm anymore then it’s about applying sunk cost theory, but he did have an option year remaining so not keeping him even as depth was just unexpected.
OF Alex Call – 3 Years 161 Days Service Time – Arbitration 2 – $1.9 MM Projected
Prediction: Non-Tendered Or Traded
Result: Avoids Arbitration Via $2.175 MM Settlement
As things currently stand, Call basically has no role with the team — as evidenced by him being left off the playoff roster — which is why my prediction went that way. However, after they likely missed out on the prime window to trade him at the deadline, retaining him now at least gives them further chance at potentially finding a partner. It also gives them insurance in the outfield if they do trade Teoscar Hernandez at some point, as he’d be a proven major leaguer to backup Josue De Paula, even though Zach Ehrhard is kinda waiting to play that role in the minors already. In the end, Call is still a bargain even at this price over the projected number and has years of control remaining, so I get why the Dodgers will retain him even if it’s just to try and trade him at a later date.
RHP Emmet Sheehan – 3 Years 63 Days Service Time – Arbitration 1 – $2.1 Million Projected
Prediction: Tendered
Result: Tendered
Emmet is going to be expected to pitch important innings for the Dodgers this year, likely with hopes that he becomes a rotation mainstay, so this was probably the second-easiest decision here. Nothing really to say.
RHP Gavin Stone – 3 Years 34 Days Service Time – Arbitration 1 – $1.2 Million Projected
Prediction: Tendered
Result: Tendered
I suppose it was always possible that the Dodgers were down on either Stone’s physical recovery from shoulder surgery or what he did in rehab appearances last year, but non-tendering a player who would likely be in the rotation for lesser teams and who has two options remaining was never realistically going to happen. Especially since, of all teams, the Dodgers need as much starting pitching insurance as possible with their fragile rotation.
OF Andy Pages – 2 Years 155 Days Service Time – Arbitration 1 – $4.9 Million Projected
Prediction: Tendered Or Extended
Result: Tendered
No extension for Pages cause it’s not necessary yet and there’s financial uncertainty in the game still, but he’s shaping up to be the connecting veteran of the coming changing of the guard on the Dodgers.
——
The 20 pre-arbitration players are Eliezer Alfonzo, Ben Casparius, Josue De Paula, Jack Dreyer, Hunter Feduccia, Jackson Ferris, Luke Fox, Alex Freeland, Paul Gervase, Seth Halvorsen, Edgardo Henriquez, Kyle Hurt, Will Klein, Landon Knack, Ronan Kopp, Dalton Rushing, Roki Sasaki, Adam Serwinowski, Justin Wrobleski, and Christian Zazueta. They appear to have all been tendered as there’s no news otherwise, which is as expected.
There’s basically no reason to not tender their contracts since they’ll be making something close to the minimum, and many of them figure to factor into next year’s plans. That said, if the Dodgers do need 40-man roster spots for additions this off-season, they have candidates for designation in at least Alfonzo, Gervase, Halvorsen, Knack, and Kopp. As mentioned before, Knack provides solid redundancy for the rotation, but being out of options for a team that loves options for depth makes him potential casualties.
======
So the Dodgers now have five arbitration cases to deal with, and things get weird from here, as January 8 is the deadline for teams and players to exchange salaries. Usually they try to reach agreements to avoid arbitration before then, like they have already with Call, but obviously that date falls after the lockout will be enacted, so I’m not exactly sure when any of this will be worked out now. Mostly a bit surprised they didn’t agree to deals with anybody else before the uncertainty of this off-season hits.
Dodgers Digest Los Angeles Dodgers Baseball Blog
